+- Lincoln Discussion Symposium (https://rogerjnorton.com/LincolnDiscussionSymposium)
+-- Forum: Lincoln Discussion Symposium (/forum-1.html)
+--- Forum: Books - over 15,000 to discuss (/forum-6.html)
+--- Thread: The President's Wife (/thread-2532.html)
The President's Wife - Eva Elisabeth - 06-28-2015 09:30 AM
In the used copy of a book I ordered was an old newspaper clipping with a review on this book, then soon to be published:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/0399111328/ref=mp_s_a_1_fkmr1_1?qid=1435501433&sr=8-1-fkmr1&pi=AC_SX110_SY165_QL70&keywords=isabell+ross+president%27s+wife
From the review it sounds an interesting read on the topic. Has any of you read it? What do you think, especially compared to the other works on Mary? Would you recommend it?
Many thanks for any feedback!
RE: The President's Wife - RJNorton - 06-28-2015 11:15 AM
It's a good book IMO, but I would place it below Jean Baker's biography in terms of thoroughness. There are notes at the end, but they tell the sources where the author got her information for each chapter; the book does not have numbered footnotes/endnotes. Basically I think folks who are sympathetic to Mary would probably enjoy the book; those who are not sympathetic would probably not enjoy this book. IMO if you have read other biographies of Mary I do not think there is much new to learn in this book.
RE: The President's Wife - Eva Elisabeth - 06-28-2015 11:42 AM
Thank you, Roger, that was a very helpful comment!
RE: The President's Wife - LincolnToddFan - 07-01-2015 10:00 PM
Thanks Roger, I've been wanting to read this book FOREVER! Eva please let me know what you think after you have read it!
RE: The President's Wife - RJNorton - 07-02-2015 06:19 AM
I will be interested in hearing what others think. One well-known Lincoln expert called the book "historical fiction" rather than "a biography."
RE: The President's Wife - Eva Elisabeth - 07-02-2015 06:42 PM
(07-02-2015 06:19 AM)RJNorton Wrote: I will be interested in hearing what others think. One well-known Lincoln expert called the book "historical fiction" rather than "a biography."I don't know if this is interesting to you, but I scanned the review I found in the book.
[attachment=1703]
RE: The President's Wife - Anita - 07-02-2015 07:05 PM
I have this book and agree with Roger's comments. IMO it's a light read and without footnotes it's hard to separate fact, fiction and opinion. Jean Baker's biography is "scholarly, factual and dispassionate" to quote an LA Times review.
Toia, you can borrow my copy.
RE: The President's Wife - LincolnToddFan - 07-03-2015 11:43 AM
Hi Anita...thanks much!
I know that Jean Baker's bio of Mary is considered seminal, and it is indeed very "dispassionate" which from the standpoint of the historian makes it very valuable.
But as a layperson who is the opposite of dispassionate I much prefer the Ruth Painter Randall biography of Mary. It's as sympathetic as can be without slipping toward whitewash, or hagiography.
RE: The President's Wife - Gene C - 07-03-2015 12:11 PM
(07-03-2015 11:43 AM)LincolnToddFan Wrote: Hi Anita...thanks much!
I know that Jean Baker's bio of Mary is considered seminal, and it is indeed very "dispassionate" which from the standpoint of the historian makes it very valuable.
But as a layperson who is the opposite of dispassionate I much prefer the Ruth Painter Randall biography of Mary. It's as sympathetic as can be without slipping toward whitewash, or hagiography.
I liked Randall's book too
RE: The President's Wife - Anita - 07-03-2015 04:39 PM
(07-03-2015 12:11 PM)Gene C Wrote:Me three.(07-03-2015 11:43 AM)LincolnToddFan Wrote: Hi Anita...thanks much!
I know that Jean Baker's bio of Mary is considered seminal, and it is indeed very "dispassionate" which from the standpoint of the historian makes it very valuable.
But as a layperson who is the opposite of dispassionate I much prefer the Ruth Painter Randall biography of Mary. It's as sympathetic as can be without slipping toward whitewash, or hagiography.
I liked Randall's book too
RE: The President's Wife - ReignetteC - 07-03-2015 05:01 PM
I'll add Catherine Clinton's "Mrs. Lincoln: A Life" to the list.
RE: The President's Wife - Anita - 07-03-2015 07:54 PM
(07-03-2015 05:01 PM)ReignetteC Wrote: I'll add Catherine Clinton's "Mrs. Lincoln: A Life" to the list.Thanks. I haven't read that one.