The Bixby Letter

[ELCore]

(01-13-2021 06:07 AM)Steve Wrote:  When I first read Emerson's article, I tended to agree with his interpretation that Lincoln meant that Hay told him that he had no knowledge of the letter when it was written - implying that Hay couldn't have written it since to write the letter he undoubtly would've had to have known about it. Although, I didn't think it was the slam dunk case for Lincoln authorship Emerson implied - Robert could've misinterpreted/misrememberd what Hay said or Hay could've been reluctant to tell Robert about his role with the letter. But I think your point about not knowing what Robert means by "special knowledge of the letter at the time" - especially since Robert speculates later in the letter that Hay may have not known about the letter at the time at all - is a very good point. Why would Robert have to speculate if Hay had definitively told Robert that he had no knowledge at all of the letter when it was originally sent? Good catch.

Thank you very much.

Quote:Unfortunately, due to "circumstances" peculiar to me; I cannot comment on the computerized stylometric analysis section of your article (at least in a way which would be fair to you) on a public forum at this time.

You can PM me if you like, especially because you have made me very curious about it. I tried to give the methodology a representation as clear and accurate as I could, but I might not have succeeded.

Quote:Even though my interpetation differs from you on the latter point, I still think your article is very good.

I admit, the last section is the weakest, and I did consider keeping it out.

Thanks for reading.