Hanging Mary

[L Verge]

I felt the same as Roger.

As for "unqualified," my interpretation of Bob's use of that term is that he is giving his assessment that the book is "totally" excellent -- not "excellent, oh! except for the constant use of incorrect grammar, and the..."

Too many reviewers try to split hairs by pronouncing someone's work as excellent and then taking the next few paragraphs to shoot down some of the parts and the writer's techniques. They are hypercritical to the point where you want to scream, "Well, did you like it or not?"