Best Generals in US History?

[Bill Richter]

I agree with Thomas Thorne in his choices and reasoning (a shock to both of us!): Winfield Scott, RE Lee, and Patton. I have a little feeling for MacArthur for the Inchon Landing in Korea, a brilliant battlefield maneuver, and his governance of Japan, and I like NB Forrest because he was a total SOB, just like me.