Louis Weichmann

[RJNorton]

(09-09-2015 05:30 PM)Eva Elisabeth Wrote:  Thanks, Roger!

Thanks, Eva. I think I shall reply with something that may get me in trouble, but in my mind, it represents what I feel.

I think there is a definite comparison/likeness between Louis Weichmann and William Herndon. We owe a great deal to both men. Herndon provided us with all sorts of information about Abraham Lincoln we would otherwise not know. Many of Lincoln's personal habits, opinions, tastes, etc. would not be known if it were not for Herndon. Louis Weichmann provided us with invaluable information about the conspirators, the boardinghouse, etc. that we would never know except for him.

At the same time I think we need to read each man's writings with caution. Did they both have an agenda that is apparent in their works? Did Herndon exaggerate his role in Lincoln's life? Did he purposely hunt for negative things about Mary Lincoln and leave out the good? Was Weichmann really the 100% Union man as he says in his book? Did he exaggerate his patriotism? Did he purposely leave out activities of his that were pro-Southern?

Were both men quite selective in their writings? Did they include only what they wanted us to know and exclude what they didn't?

What I am trying to say is that I think we need to read these men's works with discretion. They teach us a lot, but they must be read with a discerning eye.