Kennedy and Lincoln - Medical & Ballistic Comparissons

[RJNorton]

(04-03-2014 05:55 PM)Eva Elisabeth Wrote:  Roger, do you know if Francis Fisher Browne was present at the event? Since the story is also in F. Carpenter's "Six month in the White House", I wonder if Browne was also Carpenter's source - or if there was another one.

Hi Eva. I don't know if Browne was present. I did mention there are some doubters regarding this story. One of these is Dr. John Sotos. He is the doctor who feels Lincoln was dying of a rare disease called multiple endocrine neoplasia type 2B (MEN2B). Dr. Sotos writes:

"I have looked mighty hard for the first-hand account of the axe story and cannot find it.

Francis Carpenter is often cited as the primary source, but he is not. He cites a newspaper called "The NY Independent," but I think he is making it up. First, the days of the week he writes in his story don't fit the calendar. Second, I looked at all the issues of the Independent between Lincoln's Virginia visit and the publication of Carpenter's book, and the story is not there. The only substantial Lincoln material in The Independent is the long series of articles that Carpenter himself wrote. Carpenter was known to make stuff up.

I looked at every other eyewitness recollection of the hospital visits. It is pretty disjointed material. But there are at least three eyewitnesses who mention nothing about it: Sen. Sumner, Marquis de Chambrun, and a young soldier named Wilbur Fisk who wrote an effusive, detailed letter home on April 20 that did not mention axe work. It is likely that Sen. Harlan and William Crook were with him, too. Their reminiscences of that trip mention no axe work. By contrast, Keckley says that Lincoln returned to the River Queen that night so weary that he wanted to go to bed immediately."



On the other hand there is this.