+- Lincoln Discussion Symposium (https://rogerjnorton.com/LincolnDiscussionSymposium)
+-- Forum: Lincoln Discussion Symposium (/forum-1.html)
+--- Forum: Other (/forum-10.html)
+--- Thread: Elton John's new album (/thread-1212.html)
Elton John's new album - Liz Rosenthal - 10-07-2013 07:53 PM
I realize that this is completely off-topic, but since the category here is "other," and sometimes non-Lincoln topics are discussed, I thought I'd provide my amazon review of Elton John's latest album, The Diving Board. Hopefully, no one will find this objectionable. (In my defense, I do make an oblique reference to a particular phenomenon of the 1860 presidential campaign. You'll see.)
First, the link:
http://www.amazon.com/review/R338OWIG8MZ19Q/ref=cm_cr_dp_title?ie=UTF8&ASIN=B00DJZR46G&channel=detail-glance&nodeID=5174&store=music
The Diving Board is not Elton John's "first record" since The Captain and the Kid in 2006. He released a CD called The Union with Leon Russell - produced by T Bone Burnett - just three years ago. Although it was not a "solo" Elton John effort, it was as much an Elton John album as anything else he's released in his career, even if he shared top billing with his hero and mentor of 40-plus years ago. EJ co-wrote and played piano on almost all of the songs, and sang lead or backing vocals on all but one track.
As for The Diving Board, it was controversial before anyone had heard a note. Some fans were apoplectic that Elton's excellent and versatile touring band, headed by longtime EJ guitarist Davey Johnstone, was left off the new work. Fans furiously pointed fingers at T Bone Burnett, the producer on this, his second project with the Rocket Man. "Burnett is a musical tyrant!" protested some Elton John devotees on social media sites. "He is a bad, bad man who doesn't understand Elton's music!" I'm paraphrasing, but you get the idea.
The truth is that T Bone Burnett deserves a medal for drawing out the real Elton John on this recording. Burnett told Elton before they started that he'd like to see the Pinner native go back to basics. Not just back to basic rock, or back to organic music without synths and click-tracks, but a piano-bass-drums set-up, like Elton's touring band of 1970-71, which featured Nigel Olsson on drums and Dee Murray on bass. Burnett attended one of Elton's historic Troubadour concerts in Los Angeles the week of August 25, 1970, the series of shows which made EJ a star, as they say, overnight. As Elton enthusiasts know, his trio floored jaded, music industry heavies. Elton, with his voice and piano in the forefront, amazed his audience without special effects or gimmicks. He didn't even dress up (much) for this gig. With Nigel and Dee, he simply brought his songs to life through ingenious musicianship, and the sort of breast-beating vigor he still summons today, at age 66.
So T Bone Burnett now gives us the real Elton, the unadorned Elton, the barely accompanied Elton, the Elton who has not an unmusical cell in his body. His lyricist of 46 years, Bernie Taupin (who now prefers to be known as a "storyteller"), once remarked, "Elton is the most musical person I've ever met. It vibrates from him." And those vibrations sent tremors that shook the recording studio; T Bone welcomed them, nurtured them, captured them - in analog - and now it is our privilege to let them settle into our generally unmusical lives, bringing us joy, tears and plenty of tingly moments.
Elton has played piano on all of his albums, with the exception of the Complete Thom Bell Sessions (released in 1989 but dating from 1977) and the unfortunate 1979 disco release, Victim of Love. He has titillated us, made us laugh, got us dancing, or made us mourn with that piano. But compared to The Diving Board, Elton's other albums seem almost devoid of piano, seem like aural adaptations of the "Where's Waldo" game:
"Where's Elton?"
Past producers, including, occasionally, Elton himself, have more often than not treated his piano as just part of the band. An electric guitar or saxophone solo was perhaps likelier than a piano interlude in the middle of any given recording. Sometimes, even when you knew the piano was there, it was barely audible.
Elton chose noted bass guitarist Raphael Saadiq for the Diving Board sessions. Jay Bellerose on drums, who played on The Union, completes the trio. Other instruments enter the recording unobtrusively, like a garnish or brush of color. Luka Sulic and Stjepan Hauser, the two members of 2Cellos, who have toured with Elton as well as on their own, make their strings purr in spots. For a couple of songs, the twang of a pedal steel hovers shyly in the air. Horns slide in warmly a few times. Backing vocalists join here and there. Otherwise, it's just Elton and the keys.
It's evident on The Diving Board that T Bone pushed or encouraged Elton to be, in the recording studio, what he is onstage - a master of keyboard improvisation, a vocal powerhouse. Burnett gives us the Elton of the deep, lower register, that sexy lower register heard only sparingly on latter-day recordings. On The Diving Board, it dominates, especially on "Oscar Wilde Gets Out," "My Quicksand," "Home Again" and the title track, "The Diving Board."
Taupin has come through with possibly the most exciting set of lyrics - or stories - he's handed Elton in many years, if not ever. There is a knowingness in Taupin's words, from having actually lived life, that is missing from much of his most famous word-paintings, since, as a young man, he was largely writing not from life, but from books and his mind's eye. With his increased insight come lines and imagery of special elegance.
Peeling away the layers that have hidden Elton's genius in varying degrees for far too long, T Bone gives us the complete music man, as close to unvarnished as possible, as Captain Fantastic animates Taupin's words in an Elton John album like no other, the least commercial of his career, and the most daring.
Now we turn to the songs.
Oceans Away: This track, a gorgeously elegiac album-opener, featuring just piano and voice, is a vastly superior update of Tumbleweed Connection's "Talking Old Soldiers" (1971). In "Oceans Away," Taupin seems to have spent real time with nonagenarian World War Two vets reminiscing about "those that flew, those that fell, the ones that had to stay, beneath a little wooden cross, oceans away."
Oscar Wilde Gets Out: The noted 19th century Irish writer - his most familiar work being The Picture of Dorian Grey - who was imprisoned in England for being gay and, just a few years after his release, died in Paris, young (only 46), miserable and destitute, comes alive in this dramatic track. Elton's music takes several gut-wrenching turns, leaving the listener emotionally spent by the end. On this and several other tracks, Funk Brother Jack Ashford's percussion block, most famously heard in Marvin Gaye's "What's Going On," comes through, as lonely and haunting as the echoing clank of a prisoner's ball and chain.
A Town Called Jubilee: What is this song about? A farm family made homeless by foreclosure, moving to a better place, a new town serving as their "jubilee"? Or have they passed to the Great Beyond? It's hard to say. But the rustic setting, a junk-filled yard, auctioneers playing cards, and an old black dog are gently swept along in Elton's pleasing tide of jazzy, gospel chord progressions, with a bit of bluegrass guitar politely asserting itself in the background.
The Ballad of Blind Tom: This tells the true story of Blind Tom Wiggins, a sightless, autistic African-American, first a slave and then barely free, who brought fame to himself and fortune to his one-time owner as a piano-playing wizard, entertaining VIPs across America and Europe. "I may be an idiot/I may be a savant/I didn't choose this life for me/But it's somethin' that I want." Elton's driving, classically-tinged playing suggests a performance by Blind Tom himself.
Dream # 1: The first of three brief, piano instrumentals, which Elton improvised in one take, this serves, wittingly or not, as the perfect outro to "Blind Tom," with its clever integration of antebellum melodicism and Jim Crow-era ragtime.
My Quicksand: An unlucky person laments getting sucked into a life-draining relationship. "My quicksand/Welcome to my final stand/I went to Paris once/I thought I had a plan/I woke up with an accent/I wound up in quicksand." Elton sings theatrically, but in a 1950s torch song sort of way. He is wry, regretful, a nearly-willing victim. A smoky, jazz piano break, caressed by Jay Bellerose's intimate drum brush, is the romantic slow dance. But descending chords emulate the fatal scene in which the protagonist is swallowed whole.
Can't Stay Alone Tonight: This is the best country song the John/Taupin songwriting team has ever composed. In its witty sophistication and friendly, down-home imagery, it outdoes `em all: "Country Comfort," "Texan Love Song," "Dixie Lily," "Turn the Lights Out When You Leave." They are all plebeian efforts next to this one. Toby Keith, George Strait, take note. You could learn a thing or two. "Can't Stay Alone Tonight" makes you want to get out your cowboy boots and ten-gallon hat, even if you don't have any, and find the nearest country dance hall, even if you don't live near one. "Things have to change/And they might," Elton sings brightly over his rollicking country piano licks. And you believe it.
Voyeur: This is the cream of a very abundant crop, the song worth the CD purchase price all by itself. You wouldn't think that a mid-tempo ballad about voyeurism would literally grab you by the collar, shake you up and leave you sprawling in a strangely seductive back alley, but that's what this song does. Is it about a pervert who gets his jollies sneaking glimpses of embracing lovers through a keyhole or from behind a curtain? Is it about government spying? Either way, you'll love every minute of it, every titillating melodic turn. Have a warm compress handy if you need calming afterward.
Home Again: The moving first radio single from the album, it is a mini-epic, a five-minute cinematic, anguished longing for home, for the past, for whatever it is that makes one feel that need to return to one's roots. It's sad - thus, bluesy - and Elton's sweeping piano chords wash the song in symphonic tones. "We all dream of leaving/But wind up in the end/Spending all our time trying to get back home again."
Take This Dirty Water: The simplest song of the bunch, it's an infectious, straight-up African-American gospel ditty with cheerful, staccato expressions on the blacks-and-whites, a churchy, muscle-flexing lead vocal and a mischievous back-up chorus of oo-hoos, all of which put a broad smile on your face well before the end.
Dream # 2: Elton's second instrumental, slightly longer than the first, full of classical introspection, forms the perfect introduction to the next song.
The New Fever Waltz: Some may notice a faint resemblance here to "Grandma's Song" in Elton's West End theatrical smash, Billy Elliot: The Musical, but it's really a gripping update of "Where To Now, St. Peter?" the fan favorite from Tumbleweed Connection. Instead of taking a "blue canoe" to the world beyond this mortal coil, as do the U.S. Civil War dead in "St. Peter," we join a World War One cavalry soldier, dying from the flu or some other untreatable infection in that pre-penicillin age ("I was shaking with a fever/When the last good horse went down"). He glides from this life in graceful waltz steps ("Shaking with a fever/Before the white flag flew/And the ballroom opened up to us and the dancers danced on through"). It's impossible not to tear up.
Mexican Vacation (Kids in the Candlelight): After the consummated tragedy of "The New Fever Waltz," one gladly joins Elton on a fierce, blues-inflected boogie-woogie kick through a pending societal shift. Whether referring to young, would-be beneficiaries of the DREAM Act (the U.S. immigration bill languishing in Congress), or Occupy Wall Street activists, or a procession of Wide-Awakes during the 1860 presidential campaign, "Mexican Vacation" gives EJ a chance to showcase some of the rockingest chops and bluesiest growling ever to reverberate off the walls of a recording studio.
Dream # 3: This is the longest of the three instrumentals, and the most illuminating, as EJ veers into Keith Jarrett territory. Elton isn't known for playing abstract jazz, but listen to this and you'll think that's what he's been doing all of his life. Drummer Jay Bellerose taps a clever counterpoint to EJ's spontaneous musings.
The Diving Board: This is some song, this title track, bursting with feeling, a misty mix-up of jazz, blues and country, and somewhat of a "prequel" to the 1976 John/Taupin jazz ballad, "Idol," from Blue Moves. In interviews, Elton has said that "The Diving Board" is about young stars - like Justin Bieber and Lindsay Lohan - who struggle with newfound, mind-boggling fame. "Sink or swim/I can't recall who said that to me/When I was 16 and full of the world and its noise." Elton's powerful vocal, a bit Tony Bennett, a bit Frank Sinatra, tops anything else he's ever recorded in his very long, very accomplished career.
So there you have it. I would give this album more than five stars if I could!
RE: Elton John's new album - Rob Wick - 10-07-2013 08:16 PM
I've definitely heard a lot of good things about this one. I'll have to check it out.
Thanks for the review, Liz.
Best
Rob
RE: Elton John's new album - Rsmyth - 10-10-2013 11:50 AM
Hi Liz,
Great review. How would you rate this album for someone like me, who feels Yellow Brick Road was his best and probably one of my top 5 albums of all time?
RE: Elton John's new album - LincolnMan - 10-13-2013 03:02 PM
Liz: great review! My wife and daughter and I spent an hour with Elton John in 1998. He was nothing but a considerate and kind man. My favorite is also Yellow Brick Road.
RE: Elton John's new album - Eva Elisabeth - 10-13-2013 04:49 PM
Bill, are you kidding? (Have you ever washed your hands since?)
RE: Elton John's new album - LincolnMan - 10-13-2013 04:56 PM
I'm serious. My daughter went through the Make-A-Wish Foundation. She was pronounced terminal then. It was her desire to meet Elton. Although my daughter is still with us- she is chronically ill. We are thankful everyday...
RE: Elton John's new album - Eva Elisabeth - 10-14-2013 01:54 AM
Oh, Bill, it's so sad to hear your daughter is so ill! I pray it'll go on and turn out as good as ever possible and better and wish her all the best!
RE: Elton John's new album - BettyO - 10-14-2013 04:56 AM
Bill -
Make A Wish Foundation is a WONDERFUL charity - they do grand things....so glad you and your daughter got to meet Elton (I did go to one of his concerts about 1998-1999 - he's a fabulous performer!)
I pray that your daughter is doing better - and that things turn out well!
Bless you all!
RE: Elton John's new album - LincolnMan - 10-14-2013 05:26 AM
Thank you Eva and Betty. She has a good of a life as we can provide. She has an unusual taste in music. She loves Elton John and operas!
RE: Elton John's new album - Liz Rosenthal - 10-15-2013 09:36 AM
For RSmyth and LincolnMan:
Well, the album is nothing like Goodbye Yellow Brick Road. What I mean by that is, GYBR was made by a 25-year-old man who in many ways still had a kid's outlook on life and music. Now, he's 66. Obviously, he's not going to be writing songs like Saturday Night's Alright For Fighting at his age. That would be a little weird.
Elton thinks that The Diving Board is the best album of his career. I think he may be right.
If you like his piano playing, The Diving Board has more of it than any other album of his career, period. (We're talking 46 years.) He runs the gamut of styles on this album, piano-wise and melody-wise. There are uptempo, midtempo and waltz numbers. There's jazz, classical, gospel, country, and boogie woogie. The lyrics, written by his longtime songwriting partner, Bernie Taupin, are especially good here, and probably rank up there with their all-time best lyrics. There are great story-songs and really nifty turns of phrase.
Have you heard the first single off the album, Home Again? I think if you go to eltonjohn.com, you'll find the video for it there. It's a dark, mysterious song. Also, EJ will be on Live with Michael & Kelly tomorrow (Wednesday), and he will perform Home Again, and probably one other song, and will also be interviewed.
LincolnMan: How wonderful that you and your wife and daughter met EJ for a whole hour through the Make A Wish Foundation! That must have been something else. I've had the pleasure of meeting him, but definitely not for a whole hour, that's for sure! He does a lot of philanthropic work in many areas to this day, and is probably busier with it than ever.
I didn't know that your daughter had and has chronic health problems. I hope things are looking up.
RE: Elton John's new album - Rsmyth - 10-15-2013 02:04 PM
Thank you Liz. I guess I will have to give it a listen.
RE: Elton John's new album - Liz Rosenthal - 10-15-2013 02:33 PM
(10-15-2013 02:04 PM)Rsmyth Wrote: Thank you Liz. I guess I will have to give it a listen.
You definitely should!
