Awww...Peanuts - Printable Version

Awww...Peanuts - Printable Version

+- Lincoln Discussion Symposium (https://rogerjnorton.com/LincolnDiscussionSymposium)
+-- Forum: Lincoln Discussion Symposium (/forum-1.html)
+--- Forum: Assassination (/forum-5.html)
+--- Thread: Awww...Peanuts (/thread-1802.html)

Pages: 1 2 3 4

RE: Awww...Peanuts - jbarry - 09-05-2025 09:40 AM

(09-05-2025 09:07 AM)RJNorton Wrote: Thank you to Steve again. Steve writes, " I have a couple of extra things to add to my Joseph Alexander Burroughs post.

- I can't find Joseph Alexander Burroughs, yet, in the 1900 census but I did find him in the 1910 census living in Baltimore.

- In 1883 he had a son named Joseph Cornelius Burroughs who also went into the produce business. I've attached Joseph Cornelius Burroughs WWI draft card and there Joseph Cornelius clearly prefers the "Burroughs" spelling of the surname over the "Burrows" spelling.

Steve, thank you so much. This is awesome work! And thanks to Cliff for getting this started.

RE: Awww...Peanuts - RJNorton - 09-05-2025 05:32 PM

Thanks to Steve for this additional information. Steve writes, "I have a few more Burroughs/Burrows documents to post to the Forum. They're all obituaries from the Baltimore Sun. I finally found Joseph Alexander Burrows' obituary from December 1931. I also have the obituaries of three of his daughters. Two of the daughters Alice and Mary died in 1907, the same year as his wife Mary did. In fact the daughter Mary died about a week before her mother. Both daughters, like their mother, have a poem in their obituaries seemingly written by Joseph. In 1909 Joseph's daughter Emma died. There was no poem with her obituary, but I did want to point out it mentions a Roman Catholic service, which is interesting since, according to their marriage record, in 1873 Joseph and Mary were married in an Episcopal Methodist Church in Georgetown.

[Image: Burroughs700.jpg]

RE: Awww...Peanuts - jbarry - 09-06-2025 11:51 AM

This is all fantastic work! A question to the forum: Steve raises a good point that signing with an "X" does not automatically imply illiteracy. What are everyone's thoughts for and against this? My take: it's a good indicator of illiteracy, but we can't make the assumption and close research doors that might otherwise glean new details. The consensus has taken it for granted Peanuts was illiterate, perhaps to the detriment of the research. Thoughts?

RE: Awww...Peanuts - Steve - 09-06-2025 10:18 PM

According to Borroughs' trial testimony:

https://archive.org/details/conspiracytrialf01poor/page/226/mode/2up

Booth hit Borroughs with the butt of his knife and kicked him, knocking Borroughs down as Booth was mounting the horse. It's not inconceivable that Borroughs could've been injured/hurt when he was knocked down, more so if he had been holding the horse with his dominant/writing hand.

Considering the circumstances, signing a statement with an "X" soon after isn't particularly strong evidence that Peanut Burroughs was illiterate by itself.

RE: Awww...Peanuts - RJNorton - 09-08-2025 08:31 AM

Thanks to Steve for sending another clipping. He writes, "I just have an image and question to post to the Forum. In Borroughs' second statement of 24 April 1865, the transcriber listed Borroughs address as 511 10th Street. Doing a search of the 1865 directory brought up just one person at this address (or at least one person picked by the OCR reader on Ancestry.com). A Louisa Brent, widow of Thomas. Has that name ever popped up before? She could just own a boarding house, but it's probably best to check.

[Image: Burroughs800.jpg]

RE: Awww...Peanuts - J. Beckert - 09-08-2025 12:13 PM

I think Ford's Theater was 511 10th. St.

RE: Awww...Peanuts - jbarry - 09-08-2025 08:49 PM

(09-08-2025 12:13 PM)J. Beckert Wrote: I think Ford's Theater was 511 10th. St.

It has been 511 10th St. since at least 1948 (probably earlier though), but the street numbers in D.C. changed in 1869. Before that it was 454 10th St. based on the location of the Army Medical Museum address in same building from 1868.

RE: Awww...Peanuts - Steve - 09-08-2025 10:15 PM

Although it wouldn't be useful in this case the Library of Congress has a collection of Sanborn Fire Insurance maps where older addresses are located in cities:

https://www.loc.gov/collections/sanborn-maps/about-this-collection/

There's also this website that has old Sanborn maps as well:

https://sanbornfiremaps.com/

RE: Awww...Peanuts - Steve - 09-15-2025 08:34 AM

Please read Dave Taylor's response (and theory about Peanut) to Joe Barry's article:

https://lincolnconspirators.com/2025/09/15/in-the-peanut-gallery/